Test Drive Checklist — 12-Point Scorecard

Todd Mitchell (photo)
By Todd Mitchell
On: Saturday, June 13, 2026 7:38 PM
tdc

Test Drive Checklist

Choose between sedan, SUV, hatchback, pickup, coupe, wagon, minivan or convertible based on how you actually use a car. Quick 8-question quiz returns 2–3 body styles that fit.

Test Drive Checklist

14-point scored test drive checklist with verdict.

Test drive score
Passed
Failed
Verdict

How It Works

Each body style is scored against your daily commute, family size, cargo needs, off-road frequency, climate and budget. The top-matching styles surface with rationale.

Formula: Match = weighted sum of (use case × body-style suitability matrix).

How to Use This Calculator

  1. Answer 8 quick questions about your driving habits.
  2. Calculator returns ranked body styles and example models.

Worked Example

Example: 30-min suburban commute, 2 kids in car seats, monthly Costco runs, Midwest winters, $35k budget. Top match: mid-size SUV (RAV4, CR-V). Runner-up: 3-row sedan (rare). Skip: pickup, coupe.

Reference Table

Minivans win on family interior efficiency per dollar but suffer from social stigma — at the same price an SUV trades cargo for image.

Body style Best for
Sedan Daily commuters, low cargo needs, MPG priority
Hatchback City driving, occasional cargo, MPG priority
Wagon Cargo without SUV height — rare in US market
Compact SUV Small family, mixed use, winter weather
Mid-size SUV 3-row, growing family, road-trip ready
Pickup Towing, hauling, work truck, AWD without SUV
Minivan 3+ kids, max interior space, best resale per dollar
Coupe / Convertible Pleasure driving, weekend, no rear-seat needs

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I get a pickup just for the bed?

If you load the bed more than 4× per month, yes. Less than that, a hitch on an SUV or rented truck for the rare big haul costs less.

Are minivans cheaper to own than SUVs?

Often yes — by 10–20% over 5 years on the same passenger capacity. They depreciate faster but cost less new and have lower insurance.